CPMT Society CPMT Society Chapter of the Year Award
CriteriaProcedureGuidelinesSuggestions
 

Point Evaluation
The award description identifies the general activity for each of the seven categories or criteria. Although a number of criteria have a minimum level of activity, the evaluation procedure provides for performance which exceeds this minimum. On this basis, a median or midpoint score (5 point evaluation) would provide a base upon which credit can be added for good performance and reductions made for below criteria performance. Point evaluation cannot exceed 10 for any one criteria or be a negative value. The following guideline is based upon this premise and provides a more detailed description of the point evaluation system.

Technical ProgramEducational ProgramMembership AdvancementsFellow NominationsMembership DevelopmentNomination ReportMeetings Reports

Criteria 1a: Technical Program

  • May consist of meeting, tours, or full or 1/2 day conferences. Tours will be considered as 1/2 meeting credit for each tour. Full day conferences (if chapter organized and run) are considered as two meetings. Programs cannot receive credit under more than one criteria, i.e., a public affairs meeting should be listed under public affairs, a tutorial as education, and a student program or meeting as a student activity.
  • Minimum requirement - 4 technical meetings = 5 points. (Additional points can be earned for additional meetings (0.25 - 0.5 points per meeting) and quality of program, up to a maximum of 10 points total.)

Criteria 2a: Educational Program

  • May consist of multi-session courses, full day or several day seminars or tutorials, chapter organized and run home study programs offering technical training.
  • Minimum requirement - 1 educational program = 5 points. (Additional points can be earned for additional programs and quality of programs (up to 1 point per program) up to a maximum of 10 points total.)


Top of Screen

Criteria 3a: Membership Advancements
Minimum requirement - 1 advancement.
1/2 point for each member advanced. (Additional points can be earned for demonstrated advance program if sufficiently documented in the Chapter Chair's report up to a maximum of 10 points total.)

Criteria 3b: Fellow Nominations
Fellow award nominations are included in this category. Credit is given for nominations of award. Award need not have been approved. Minimum requirement - 1 nomination = 5 points. (Additional points can be earned for demonstrated program or additional nominations (1 point per nomination to a maximum of 3 points), plus 2 points for showing an active plan to groom potential nominees.)


Top of Screen

Criteria 4: Membership Development
Minimum requirement - any increase in Chapter membership = 2 points. Scoring = 1/2 point for each increase in membership. (Additional points can be earned for additional increases and for demonstrating a membership development program that includes recruiting, retaining, recovering and recognizing members. Activities may also include participation in the IEEE GOLD Program. Up to a maximum of 10 points total.)

Criteria 5a: Nomination Report
Nomination report must be well written, clear and must be structured in such a way that evaluators can judge the relative merits of each item. (5 points for fully acceptable article. Fewer points for less organized article or confusing data.

Criteria 5b: Meeting Reports
Minimum requirement - submittal of meeting reports for 4 meetings = 5 points.

Weighting Factors
Each of the seven specific criteria listed above has a maximum score of either 5 or 10 points. A chapter's final score is determined by adding these scores after they have been multiplied by the following weighting factors:

1aTechnical Program(weighting 3.0)
2aEducational Program(weighting 2.5)
3aMembership Advancements(weighting 1.0)
3bFellow Nominations(weighting 1.0)
4Membership Development(weighting 1.5)
5aNomination Report(weighting 1.0)
5bMeeting Reports(weighting 1.0)

Base upon the above maximum of 5 or 10 points per criteria and the weighting factors listed above, the maximum score is 100 points.

Technical ProgramEducational ProgramMembership AdvancementsFellow NominationsMembership DevelopmentNomination ReportMeetings Reports

General Information, Criteria, Procedure, Suggestions for Report, Top of Screen
CPMT Society Publications | Technical Committees | Chapters | Conferences | Educational Opportunities | Awards | Membership
Contact CPMT